Find a top-rated insurance agency in Toronto, Ontario
415 Toronto agencies scored on real Google reviews, from auto and home to business and life coverage, so you can compare before you call.
Ranked by a published rubric from recent Google reviews. Browse the map →
Browse Toronto insurance agencies by specialty
Auto, home and property, life, business and commercial, health and travel, multi-carrier brokers, and bilingual service, all scored side by side.
Top picks by project type
The current #1 for each service, ranked by score and relevance.
Not sure which type you need?Find match →
Why Toronto shoppers trust this guide
An independent, data-driven directory, not a pay-to-list ad board.
415 agencies, one consistent scorecard
We've scored 415 Toronto insurance agencies against the same review criteria, averaging 4.09 out of 5, so you're comparing apples to apples across auto, home, life, business, health and travel, and bilingual service.
We surface the real patterns in reviews
Themes like knowledgeable and patient staff, competitive rates, and personalized service show up dozens of times in our data, and we flag recurring complaints like slow phone response too, so you know what to expect before you sign up.
Earned rankings, updated monthly, no pay-to-play
Dave De Vries oversees the rankings, data refreshes monthly, and each listing carries a last-verified date. Agencies can't buy a better spot here, the ranking is purely earned from review performance.
How we rank Toronto insurance agencies
One published rubric scores each business 0–100 from recent public Google reviews: rating, review volume, recency, sentiment, and profile completeness. No pay-to-rank, no edited reviews.
- ✓ Sentiment synthesised from real reviews, not republished
- ✓ Google-verified businesses clearly marked
- ✓ Refreshed regularly so scores stay current
Best-of rankings
All rankings →Guides
All guides →- Finding a bilingual insurance broker in Toronto
Why working with a bilingual insurance broker in Toronto can matter for coverage decisions, and how to find one for your language.
- Helping an aging parent review and update their insurance coverage
A practical, respectful way to help an aging parent review their auto, home, and life insurance, and spot coverage that no longer fits their situation.
- How an insurance claim works in Ontario, from report to payout
A step-by-step look at how an insurance claim moves from first report to payout, what to expect, and how to keep the process moving.
- Ways to lower your insurance premiums in Ontario without cutting coverage
Practical ways Ontario households can lower auto, home, life, and business insurance premiums without leaving themselves underinsured.
Areas we cover
insurance agency across Toronto, Ontario. Pick your area to see who serves it, or get matched.