Insurance agency in Scarborough

70 insurance agencies serve Scarborough, Ontario. 17 are based in the city with an average 4.1 Google rating. Top providers: Mark James Insurance Brokers, Co-op

Seventy insurance agencies serve Scarborough, with 17 based right in the city and the closest operator just 1.2 km away. The agencies listed here carry an average Google rating of 4.1.

Top-rated providers include Mark James Insurance Brokers o/a A Division of Oracle RMS, Co-operators - Vel Insurance Services Inc, and Maxxlife Financial Inc.

Providers serving: 70
Avg rating: 4.1★
Nearest provider: 1.2 km
Based in Scarborough: 17

Top-scored insurance agency serving Scarborough

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to Scarborough. How we score ›

Mark James Insurance Brokers o/a A Division of Oracle RMS

4.9(58)✓ Google-verified

Mark James delivers hands-on, personal service from staff like Mark, Saeed, and Daniel, who take time to explain coverage options and find competitive rates without pressure. One significant exception: a reviewer reported initial promises did not match post-sale experience, with unclear communication, policy mistakes, and rates that disappointed.

Independent Multi-Carrier BrokerAuto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Co-operators - Vel Insurance Services Inc

3.6(49)✓ Google-verified

Staff like Jenna, Stephanie, and Senthu earn repeated praise for explaining insurance options clearly and answering calls promptly. Customers report smooth coverage setup, savings of thousands on premiums, and genuinely attentive service. Two complaints cite dismissive phone interactions where staff did not listen carefully before responding. The business handles auto, home, tenant, travel, and business insurance across Toronto and Scarborough. Travel insurance specifically drew praise for decoding confusing options. Reviewers name specific staff members often, suggesting consistent service, though occasional phone interactions fall short of the standard set by top performers.

Independent Multi-Carrier BrokerBilingual / Multilingual ServiceAuto Insurance

View profile

72 low data

Maxxlife Financial Inc

5.0(64)✓ Google-verified

Every review praises Manoj's knowledge, responsiveness, and ability to match policies to individual needs without unnecessary wait. The standout is speed: one customer got family coverage in hours on urgent request, and others note he answers calls and emails promptly, even during holidays.

Life InsuranceHealth & Travel Insurance

View profile

Multi Risk Insurance & Financial Group Inc.

3.7(173)✓ Google-verified

Multi Risk acts as a broker matching clients to carriers, and individual brokers like Charan Singh Rai, Navdeep Kaur, and Gurseerat earn consistent praise for finding competitive quotes and staying responsive even on weekends. But the brokerage's claim support is a sore point: one client waited months on a stolen vehicle claim while another discovered policy gaps only when filing, both citing minimal broker advocacy and silence. Staff quality swings sharply. Several brokers excel at listening and explaining options clearly. Others ignore follow-ups, show frustration with existing customers, or fail to deliver promised coverage. Billing surprises (a $100 jump without explanation) add to the sense that once a policy is sold, some clients feel abandoned.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier BrokerBilingual / Multilingual Service

View profile

72 low data

Billyard Insurance Group - North York

4.9(91)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers praise individual agents (Omar, Nate Cao, Kat Cheng, Farhang) for patience and responsiveness, especially helping newcomers to Canada understand local insurance. A small number report serious processing failures: one claims a cancellation was ignored and they were charged a second year of premiums; another says a discount was lost during a policy transfer and took months unresolved. Staff competence is high, but administrative follow-up appears inconsistent.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier BrokerBilingual / Multilingual Service

View profile

72 low data

Visitors to Canada Insurance

4.9(41)✓ Google-verified

Most visitors buying travel or health coverage report smooth, quick transactions with attentive staff who explain options clearly. One past complaint about cancellation fees emerged; the business responded to that concern.

Life InsuranceHealth & Travel Insurance

View profile

61 low data

Insurance Tiger

3.7(82)✓ Google-verified

Insurance Tiger works well when you land an engaged agent like Turkan or Dev Singh, who handle rate shopping and policy changes promptly. Staff quality varies sharply; some reviewers praise years of attentive service, while others report unresponsive brokers, defensive behaviour when shopping competitors, and surprises like pending balances not disclosed upfront.

Auto Insurance

View profile

56 low data

Best Visitors To Canada Insurance

5.0(7)✓ Google-verified

Rohan and his team handle visitor and Supervisa insurance with real patience, answering questions that stretch into visas, travel, and health concerns without complaint. Customers report straightforward pricing, zero pressure, and follow-ups after policies are in place.

Health & Travel Insurance

View profile

42 low data

Life Insurance Company of North America

3.0(1)

One reviewer noted responsive service but flagged an inconsistent first-time experience, though signaled openness to returning.

Life Insurance

View profile

#10

49 low data

Vendor Insurance Ltd

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Both reviews highlight fast service. Stephen delivered an insurance certificate within an hour; staff answer calls promptly and treat customers well. Only 2 reviews limit the breadth of evidence.

Auto InsuranceBusiness & Commercial InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

#11

64 low data

INFINITE INSURANCE FINANCIAL CORP.

4.8(16)✓ Google-verified

Nestor Blumwald and his team excel at life insurance and financial planning with strong long-term client relationships. Reviewers consistently praise his integrity, quick responses, and willingness to go above and beyond, especially during claims and family crises. One older complaint about auto insurance delays is an outlier in an otherwise consistently positive record.

Life Insurance

View profile

#12

37 low data

The Great-West Life Assurance Company

3.4(18)✓ Google-verified

Staff quality swings sharply: some callers report helpful, courteous service while others hit rude or dismissive representatives. The bigger frustration is reaching anyone at all; reviewers repeatedly mention difficulty getting a live agent, transferred to the right department, or getting callbacks. Speed also comes up as a concern.

Life Insurance

View profile

Your enquiry may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.