Insurance agency in Etobicoke

Find 218 insurance agencies serving Etobicoke, including 21 based locally. Compare top-rated providers and get quotes for home, auto, and business coverage.

You'll find 218 insurance agencies serving Etobicoke, with 21 based right in the city. Most nearby operators are less than a kilometer away, making it simple to reach local support. Top-rated providers in the area include Lilian Hee-Karstadt Desjardins Insurance Agent, Billyard Insurance Group - Queensway, and Lorrie Howe Desjardins Insurance Agent, which average 3.9 stars across Google reviews.

Providers serving: 218
Avg rating: 3.9★
Nearest provider: 0.9 km
Based in Etobicoke: 21

Top-scored insurance agency serving Etobicoke

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to Etobicoke. How we score ›

Lilian Hee-Karstadt Desjardins Insurance Agent

4.9(230)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently report fast responses and smooth quote turnarounds, with several mentioning speed compared to online brokers. Named agents Qamar, Kris, Raman, Scarlett, and Devam receive repeated praise for knowledge, approachability, and customer-first service; many customers span 10-15+ years with the agency. Insurance covers auto (including motorcycle), home, and life policies. Reviewers highlight competitive rates and help navigating coverage gaps that online tools missed. Customers value the personal touch and ease of reaching agents directly.

Life InsuranceAuto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Billyard Insurance Group - Queensway

5.0(170)✓ Google-verified

Across hundreds of reviews spanning years, staff like Taya, Abdul, and Khrystyna consistently go beyond basic broker work: they listen, explain trade-offs clearly, and hunt competitive quotes without pressure. Reviewers praise their speed, how easy they are to reach, and the calm they bring to otherwise stressful insurance decisions. The business handles auto, home, and rental policies across Ontario and into Atlantic and Western Canada. Repeat clients come back because the team remembers them and keeps working to save them money on renewals. No patterns of complaints appear in the feedback.

Auto InsuranceBusiness & Commercial InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Lorrie Howe Desjardins Insurance Agent

4.7(384)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently praise quick, patient staff who take time to explain options clearly. Ashley, Ruchika, and Lorrie are named repeatedly for going above and beyond on quotes and claims. One serious complaint: a policy cancellation request sent by email and confirmed as canceled was not processed, leading to unexpected charges after the vehicle was sold. The complaint was only resolved after calling Desjardins directly. The team handles auto, home, and life coverage with a reputation for competitive rates and long-term client relationships. Multiple reviewers mention staying 30+ years or coming to them for multiple policies. Claims processing receives specific praise for being handled smoothly, though the one cancellation failure raises a red flag on follow-through with administrative requests.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceLife Insurance

View profile

Active Insurance & Financial Group Inc.

4.2(52)✓ Google-verified

Strong experiences centre on staff like Tiffany Banate and Anabela De Medeiros, who answer quickly, explain coverage clearly, and secure competitive rates. A cottage insurance closing next day shows speed; long-term clients praise reliability and after-hours availability. Complaints point to inconsistent service quality-some staff are dismissive or evasive about pricing, creating frustration that outweighs isolated shortcomings for most.

Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

Insurance Explorer Inc.

4.9(238)✓ Google-verified

Insurance Explorer Inc. earns consistent five-star ratings for making visitor and Super Visa insurance approachable. Yesu Babu stands out for patient explanations, quick responses, and helping families find policies that fit their budget without pressure.

Auto InsuranceHealth & Travel InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

Allstate Insurance: Toronto West Agency

3.8(157)✓ Google-verified

Five-star reviews consistently praise individual agents like Gurdeep, Jamal, Melissa, and Deshan for responsiveness, clear explanations, and competitive quotes. Customers say the process is smooth and agents actually listen to their needs. However, one-star reviews point to significant friction: calls take 45 to 60 minutes to answer, claims drag on for weeks, and the promised 24-hour chat is hard to find. The tension suggests strong agent work undercut by company-wide bottlenecks. Reviewers who worked directly with named staff report saving hundreds or thousands on premiums and feeling well-informed about coverage options. The complaint pattern is distinct: it hits hardest with customers already in a claim, calling during busy hours, or trying to cancel. Those dealing with an agent one-on-one generally had smooth experiences.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Billyard Insurance Group - Etobicoke

4.7(735)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently praise Naiem Othman, Zulair, AmirSam, Shruti Rawat, and other brokers for taking time to explain options, finding competitive quotes, and handling paperwork smoothly. Staff show genuine care and remain available for questions after purchase. The group handles auto, home, and RV insurance across Etobicoke. Customers note that quotes from Billyard beat competing brokers. Multiple clients have used the same broker for years with consistent professional service and responsiveness.

Auto InsuranceBilingual / Multilingual ServiceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Reliable Insurance Brokers

4.9(166)✓ Google-verified

Reliable Insurance Brokers earns consistent five-star praise for broker-led consultations that unpack complex policies and find concrete savings. Reviewers name staff members repeatedly: Paige, Krystal, Navalpreet, Alex, Adnan, Daniel, and Thomas all appear in multiple reviews crediting them for clear explanations, rapid turnarounds, and rates that often beat previous policies by thousands annually. Staff handle auto, home, business, and multi-policy bundling with equal care. One reviewer accidentally reached the firm instead of their original insurer and received such thorough, patient help they switched anyway. Paperwork moves fast even under deadline pressure. The standout is how brokers take time to audit existing coverage before quoting new ones, catching coverage gaps and deductible improvements.

Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness & Commercial Insurance

View profile

Westland Insurance

5.0(8)✓ Google-verified

Over eight years, customers return to Westland for staff who answer fast and stay calm under pressure. Named advisors like Silvia, Sonia, Halyna, and Kris handle everything from food trailers to city forms with honesty and a smile.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier BrokerHome & Property Insurance

View profile

#10

Life, Health and Travel Insurance Advisor Lineth Orea

5.0(98)✓ Google-verified

Lineth Orea delivers consistently attentive service across travel, health, and life insurance. Reviewers praise her patient explanations, affordable coverage, and direct responsiveness; she builds trust by matching policies to individual budgets and needs without pressure.

Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceHealth & Travel Insurance

View profile

#11

69 low data

Travel Shield Canada Insurance Plan

4.2(119)✓ Google-verified

Travel Shield offers travel and health insurance with staff like Gurdeep praised for patient guidance at purchase, but recent reviews report serious claims problems: denials without explanation, months-long waits, and unanswered contact. The split between glowing five-stars and one-star complaints about post-sale experience is stark. Note: Evidence is limited to review text only; detail is incomplete.

Health & Travel InsuranceLife Insurance

View profile

#12

52 low data

Markus Agyeman-Vachon Insurance

3.7(3)

Markus Agyeman-Vachon offers personal and commercial insurance in Etobicoke with 20 years claimed experience. Reviewers report significant savings on high-risk auto policies and willingness to help evenings and weekends, though one recent review raised reliability questions. Limited review evidence.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

Your enquiry may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.