Insurance agency in North York

Insurance agencies serving North York, Toronto. 33 local brokers, 266 covering the area. Average rating 3.9. Find quotes from Familia Life, CoreService, ThinkIn

Finding insurance in North York is straightforward. 33 agencies operate from within the city, and 266 providers in the broader area cover residents here, with the nearest option just 0.1 km away. The agencies listed below average a 3.9 Google rating.

Top-rated local choices include Familia Life, CoreService Insurance Brokers Inc, and ThinkInsure. Use this directory to compare coverage options and get quotes from brokers near you.

Providers serving: 266
Avg rating: 3.9★
Nearest provider: 0.1 km
Based in North York: 33

Top-scored insurance agency serving North York

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to North York. How we score ›

Familia Life

5.0(31)✓ Google-verified

Richard Kim at Familia Life consistently guides clients through coverage decisions with patience and clarity, walking them through each step without pressure. Reviewers praise his knowledge, quick response times, and ability to find affordable rates, with many noting policies were approved within days even for clients with medical histories that blocked other insurers. The business excels at explaining complex options and matching policies to individual circumstances. Clients repeatedly name Richard as the reason they chose Familia Life, highlighting his professional yet approachable manner and willingness to answer all questions thoroughly before anyone commits to a purchase.

Life Insurance

View profile

75 low data

CoreService Insurance Brokers Inc

4.9(198)✓ Google-verified

CoreService brokers consistently help clients save money and navigate insurance terms clearly, often within a day. One complaint flagged commission bias and targeting of non-English speakers, though the 97% five-star rate and named staff praise (Min Suk, Sean Kim, Rachel Park, Thomas Yoo, Piljong Roh, Trisha, Haleem Lee) suggest this is not the norm.

Auto InsuranceBusiness & Commercial InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

ThinkInsure

4.6(1613)✓ Google-verified

Some brokers deliver exceptional service with clear communication and fair pricing, but accessing them means fighting phone queues that routinely exceed an hour. When brokers engage directly, customers experience smooth processes and transparent explanations; the problem is reaching them at all. Recent reviews show declining responsiveness since a corporate acquisition, with customers repeatedly reporting unanswered calls, missed callbacks, and days-long delays for basic questions, especially frustrating near renewal deadlines. Customers who persevere through hold times often land with attentive staff like Dylan Smith, Patrick, or Darryl, who manage policies with speed and care. However, quote accuracy issues and billing errors have damaged trust, and the contrast between instant quote-request callbacks and hours-long holds for existing customers suggests the operation prioritizes lead capture over ongoing support.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceLife Insurance

View profile

High Risk Insurance Broker - Sound Insurance Services Inc Associates

4.8(140)✓ Google-verified

Most clients get their insurance sorted within hours or days, often beating other brokers' quotes by significant margins. Glen D'Rozario, Richard, and Tino stand out for securing policies when clients had exhausted other options-including late evening and after-hours work-and keeping buyers informed throughout. Two reviewers encountered hostile, dismissive service, suggesting inconsistent staff performance across appointments.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

59 low data

Travel Medical Insurance - Stonewell Financial Service Inc

5.0(12)✓ Google-verified

All 12 reviews praise Stonewell's claims service, particularly Lucy Park and Justin's personal attention to coverage disputes and documentation. Reviewers highlight fluent Korean-English service and willingness to resolve coverage questions, with specific praise for handling dental, hospitalization, and post-treatment X-rays overseas.

Health & Travel Insurance

View profile

Sound Insurance Services Inc.

4.3(450)✓ Google-verified

Gautam Banerjee, Rutul, and Richard earn strong praise for clarity, speed, and respect. Yet several recent complaints cite unauthorized coverage downgrades, dramatic price hikes after quotes, ignored emails, and staff rudeness. Service quality appears inconsistent, depending on which broker you're assigned.

Bilingual / Multilingual Service

View profile

Insurdinary

4.9(835)✓ Google-verified

Insurdinary staff (Gabriel Rojas, Prakash Kaur, Dylan A., and Mary) consistently earn praise for patient, detailed explanations of travel and auto insurance options without pressure. Reviewers highlight how agents walk through coverage step-by-step, answer questions thoroughly, and follow up efficiently-creating a calm, consultative experience.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

61 low data

Allstate Insurance: Toronto Centre Agency

4.2(84)✓ Google-verified

Strong praise centres on named agents, particularly Octobre Opilas and Danny Zhang, who explain coverage clearly and respond promptly. Complaints focus on long phone waits and slow replies to policy updates and refund requests.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Co-operators

4.0(62)✓ Google-verified

Most five-star reviews highlight Asma and other advisers who deliver patient, knowledgeable service at competitive rates for auto, home, and life insurance. Yet one-star complaints centre on unreturned calls, non-existent handoffs between staff, and occasional rudeness, leaving prospective clients unsure whether they will reach a helpful person or get ignored.

Independent Multi-Carrier BrokerBilingual / Multilingual ServiceAuto Insurance

View profile

Best Insurance Ontario | Life Insurance Broker

#10

50 low data

Best Insurance Ontario | Life Insurance Broker

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Two five-star reviews from long-term clients highlight tailored retirement and insurance planning, with particular praise for advisor Belen Victoria-Gsoll's empathetic, responsive approach and the breadth of services (RRIF income funds, critical illness, travel insurance). Limited review volume.

Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

#11

Connect Insurance Inc

4.8(401)✓ Google-verified

Most clients experience attentive, patient advisors who take time to explain coverage options, uncover gaps, and find rates that fit their budget and family needs. Staff like Mahan Salasel, Bahareh Behzad, and Vida earn trust through detailed policy reviews, responsive follow-up via portal and phone, and genuine advocacy even during claims and difficult conversations. One client reported a sharp drop in service when requesting cancellation, describing an advisor as unhelpful and providing incorrect settlement information rather than professional guidance. This was an isolated incident in a predominantly five-star record but worth considering if your experience involves policy changes or claims disputes.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

#12

Co-operators - Delvand Insurance Agency Ltd

4.0(54)✓ Google-verified

Delvand Insurance earns strong praise when dealing directly with agent Donya Ziafati, who reviewers credit with patient explanations, responsive service, and securing competitive rates. The agency delivers smooth auto and home quote experiences and reportedly saves customers $200+ monthly compared to competitors. However, recent complaints reveal serious policy administration issues: customers face surprise premium hikes after cancellation notices, refusal of handwritten bills of sale despite being standard in private sales, and downstream damage to insurance rates elsewhere. One seven-year loyal customer with zero claims was penalized for delayed vehicle sale notification, a red flag for contract handling.

Bilingual / Multilingual ServiceAuto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Your enquiry may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.