Insurance agency in Markham

Find insurance agencies in Markham, Ontario. 69 providers cover the area, with 22 based locally. Average rating 4.1 stars.

Sixty-nine insurance agencies serve Markham, with 22 based right in the city. Most people can reach an insurer within about 2.2 km, and local providers average a 4.1 Google rating. Top-rated options include Billyard Insurance Group in Markham South, Aviva Canada, and Cornell Insurance Brokers Ltd.

Providers serving: 69
Avg rating: 4.1★
Nearest provider: 2.2 km
Based in Markham: 22

Top-scored insurance agency serving Markham

Ranked by recent Google reviews, weighted for proximity to Markham. How we score ›

Billyard Insurance Group - Markham South

4.9(96)✓ Google-verified

Billyard Insurance Group's staff, particularly brokers Richie Yu, Joanna Ho, Tracy Guo, and Eric, earn praise for solving insurance problems at speed even on weekends and after hours. Customers value their patience in explaining coverage details and willingness to work with non-native English speakers; multiple reviews highlight urgent renewals or business-launch scenarios resolved within 24 hours. One older complaint mentions an unresolved issue after two contact attempts. The overwhelming pattern is consistent, reliable individual service rather than company-wide operations criticism.

Bilingual / Multilingual ServiceAuto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Aviva Canada

4.5(5566)✓ Google-verified

Most reviewers report quick, courteous claims service with staff who explain next steps clearly and resolve issues in days. However, a vocal minority struggle with administrative missteps (wrong policy copies sent, accounts accessed without consent), unclear communication, and difficulty reaching responsive support.

Auto InsuranceLife InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

Cornell Insurance Brokers Ltd

4.7(124)✓ Google-verified

Reviewers consistently praise named brokers-Kyle Eggett, Vince Lau, Rick, Jennika Page-for expertise, accessibility, and finding rates well below competitors. Turnaround is often same-day or under 24 hours, with staff working outside normal hours when needed. One recent customer saw rates jump $2,500 annually post-acquisition and felt abandoned when seeking relief; the broker then sent the debt to collections despite submitted termination notice. Long-standing clients report years of reliability and professional follow-through. The team's strength lies in individual broker relationships rather than institutional process. Most cite specific savings of $1,000-plus and appreciate the time taken to explain coverage options in detail, though this depth isn't universal across all staff.

Independent Multi-Carrier BrokerAuto InsuranceHome & Property Insurance

View profile

73 low data

LSM Insurance

4.9(89)

Nearly all reviewers praise LSM's experienced team for patient, pressure-free guidance on life insurance choices. Lorne Marr and his advisors are noted for answering quickly, understanding client needs, and avoiding high-pressure tactics.

Life Insurance

View profile

68 low data

Marathon Insurance Group

4.8(47)✓ Google-verified

Most customers report fast quotes, competitive rates, and agents who explain coverage clearly. Named staff like David, Carolyn, and Nickie earn repeated praise for responsiveness and persistence in finding discounts. One customer had a starkly different experience: a commercial car quote jumped from $6,035 to $7,296 over two weeks, with final delays blamed on a mileage glitch.

Independent Multi-Carrier BrokerLife Insurance

View profile

Merit Insurance Brokers Inc

4.8(101)✓ Google-verified

Clients stay for decades because Merit responds quickly and delivers clear advice without the runaround. Named brokers like Carolyn Vickers, Doug Berry, and Brandi Matthews earn repeated mention for handling claims promptly, managing account changes easily, and staying accessible when it matters.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

SN Insurance Brokers

5.0(12)

Pooja and Sachin earn consistent praise for securing competitive rates and staying accessible through the entire buying process. Clients return for years, citing their patience, knowledge, and willingness to help outside regular hours during claims.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

Globe Life

4.8(21)

Most clients experience friendly, knowledgeable service focused on understanding their needs rather than pushing sales. Ashley Charriere appears frequently in positive feedback for explaining options clearly and helping people find policies that fit their goals. One serious complaint about high-pressure tactics and unprofessional conduct from another agent stands out as an exception.

Life Insurance

View profile

54 low data

Insurance Broker - Car / Auto / Home / Commercial / CGL / E&O - Sunny Sidhu

5.0(5)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

All five Google reviews are five-star. Clients praise Sunny Sidhu for finding competitive auto insurance rates (even for high-risk drivers), handling paperwork, and guiding them through complex situations with patience and professionalism. One reviewer credited his coverage choices with saving thousands on a total-loss claim.

Auto InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier BrokerHealth & Travel Insurance

View profile

#10

57 low data

No Medical Life Insurance

4.9(9)Publishes prices

Reviewers consistently praise this agency for making life insurance accessible to people with health issues like diabetes, cancer, and stroke. Information is clear and straightforward, with helpful articles that cut through typical sales language.

Life Insurance

View profile

#11

57 low data

Travel Insurance Office Inc. (TIO)

4.6(14)✓ Google-verified

Most reviews praise TIO's knowledgeable staff, quick responses, and competitive pricing on travel insurance. One dissatisfied customer criticized them for unable to help with a claim dispute through their Zurich coverage.

Health & Travel InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

#12

47 low data

ASK Insurance Brokers Inc.

5.0(1)

Limited review evidence: one five-star rating on record. Their website lists auto, motorcycle, home, condo, commercial, and health insurance products across personal and business lines.

Independent Multi-Carrier Broker

View profile

Your enquiry may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based solely on our published scoring method and are not affected by referral fees.