How long does it take to get a new policy in place?

Customers report new policies completed within a few days.

Can I bundle my home and auto insurance?

Yes; bundling home and auto policies is standard practice and customers report significant monthly savings.

How quickly do agents respond to questions?

James and Jamie are described as quick to respond with no waiting; customers praise their availability.

Hayter Fisher Insurance Brokers Ltd

Updated 2026-07-24 · 1,697 reviewed · 415 listed · Scored from 136 Google reviews · How we rank ›

5.0(136) 91 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified

Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness & Commercial InsuranceHealth & Travel InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier Broker

Services: Auto Insurance, Home & Property Insurance, Life Insurance
Reviews: 136

What recent reviews say

Over decades of serving London, Hayter Fisher has earned trust through quick responses and clear explanations. James and Jamie handle each case personally, bundling policies to save customers money and walking them through every step without jargon.

The firm makes insurance feel straightforward rather than painful. Families renew repeatedly and refer friends with confidence. Multi-year loyalty is common, with customers grateful for the ease of the electronic process and follow-up that keeps them informed as circumstances change.

Praised for

responsive and quick to answer
explains coverage clearly
finds competitive rates
staff personable and knowledgeable
simple process makes insurance easy

responsive-agentfair-pricingknowledgeable-staffhelpful-adviceeasy-to-reachpolicy-claritypersonalized-servicegreat-follow-uptrustworthy

Best for: Families and individuals wanting an agent who explains options clearly and responds fast.

Strengths

Over 90 years operating locally
staff respond quickly and explain policies clearly
find competitive rates and bundle discounts
bundle home and auto policies to save money

Worth knowing

James and Jamie named as primary contacts, both praised for responsiveness and knowledge
staff bundle home and auto policies to achieve cost savings
electronic process praised for convenience
modular home insurance sourced successfully where previous broker could not
multi-decade customer relationships common (20+ years mentioned, 30+ years mentioned)

What reviews say by service

Auto Insurance: James and Jamie praised for quick quotes, clear coverage explanation, and competitive rates on renewals.
Home & Property Insurance: Strong track record including successful modular home coverage where other brokers failed; bundling with auto saves customers money.
Independent Multi-Carrier Broker: Brokers shop multiple carriers to find best rates and options; customers note significant monthly savings after switching.
Business & Commercial Insurance: Mentioned in services offered on website; no direct review evidence in recent reviews.
Health & Travel Insurance: Mentioned in services offered on website; no direct review evidence in recent reviews.
Life Insurance: Mentioned in services offered on website; no direct review evidence in recent reviews.

How it compares

Rated 5 against a 4.08 average across the 263 auto insurance businesses listed here.
Has more Google reviews than 84% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method

Star rating 91

Review volume 93

Review recency 100

Review sentiment 81

Profile completeness 100

Verification 30

Rating breakdown

134

Common questions

How long does it take to get a new policy in place?: Customers report new policies completed within a few days.
Can I bundle my home and auto insurance?: Yes; bundling home and auto policies is standard practice and customers report significant monthly savings.
How quickly do agents respond to questions?: James and Jamie are described as quick to respond with no waiting; customers praise their availability.

Contact

Phone: +1519-685-2344
Website: https://hayterfisher.com/
Address: 721 Exeter Rd, London, ON N6E 1L3
Open in Google Maps

Last verified 2026-07-24

Opening hours

Monday: 08:30-16:30
Tuesday: 08:30-16:30
Wednesday: 08:30-16:30
Thursday: 08:30-16:30
Friday: 08:30-16:30
Saturday: Closed
Sunday: Closed

As listed on Google.

From their website

Services listed

Home insuranceAuto insuranceFarm insuranceCommercial insuranceMarine insuranceMotorhome/Travel Trailer insuranceBusiness insurance

Operating:since 1934

As published by the business on its own website; not independently verified.

Request a quote

Similar insurance agency nearby

Sutherland Elliott Insurance Brokers & Thames Financial

4.3(23)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Reviewers consistently praise Angelica Blanco for attentive, personalized service and her ability to find better rates than competitors. Recent experience across multiple clients shows thorough, bilingual support that genuinely listens to customer needs and defends on pricing. However, older complaints flag serious service breakdowns: unauthorized policy changes, lost documents, and financial errors that staff refused to correct. These issues coincide with reported staff changes, suggesting inconsistency over time.

Health & Travel Insurance

View profile

Westland Insurance

4.4(81)✓ Google-verified

Westland brokers like Sakshi, Mandeep, and Harmanjit earn strong praise for fast, attentive service and knowledgeable policy advice that feels personal. Clients report smooth renewals and claim guidance. Service consistency breaks down when assigned brokers are unavailable or leave. Callers struggle to reach reps, waits stretch days, and some experience unexplained policy changes or attempted withdrawals after clear instructions not to charge. Phone accessibility remains the sharpest pain point.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceBusiness & Commercial Insurance

View profile