Toronto, Ontario Insurance Agency Guide
Menu

Mitch Insurance Brokers

Updated 2026-07-24 · 1,697 reviewed · 415 listed · Scored from 940 Google reviews · How we rank ›

4.7(940) 85 composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified Publishes prices
Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceLife InsuranceBusiness & Commercial InsuranceHealth & Travel InsuranceIndependent Multi-Carrier BrokerBilingual / Multilingual Service
Mitch Insurance Brokers
Services
Auto Insurance, Home & Property Insurance, Life Insurance
Reviews
940

What recent reviews say

Clients consistently praise individual brokers by name for speed, expertise, and genuine care. Trevor, Katie, Daniela, and Krystah deliver quick turnarounds, patient explanations, and savings that beat competitors. A handful report hitting dead phones, gaps in follow-through, and service that has deteriorated over time.

The strength lies in personal relationships: named staff members handle complex situations smoothly and earn repeat business. Newer customers especially value quick quoting and transparent coverage talks. Friction appears when volume overwhelms the team, leaving some voicemails unanswered and frustrated clients waiting on hold.

Praised for
  • staff knowledge and professionalism
  • fast response times and follow-up
  • cost savings and competitive quotes
  • patient, personable service
Watch-outs
  • poor phone accessibility
  • inconsistent service quality
  • feeling unheard during difficult situations
responsive-agentfair-pricingknowledgeable-staffpersonalized-servicefast-claims-processeasy-to-reachhelpful-advicehard-to-reach
Best for: Clients who value one-on-one broker relationships and want detailed coverage explanations.
Think twice if: Phone lines can go unanswered during busy periods; service quality may vary if your broker leaves.

Strengths

  • named brokers known for personalized attention
  • fast quoting and competitive rates
  • explain coverage clearly
  • handle complex transitions smoothly

Worth knowing

  • Trevor praised for speed, cost savings, and handling complex cases
  • Katie Young noted for patience, professionalism, and quick responses across multiple clients
  • Daniela Casselman mentioned for detailed explanations and going above and beyond
  • Krystah and Krystal Barr cited for knowledge and patience
  • Kassandra Gill commended for responsiveness and thorough follow-up
  • Some clients report 20-minute hold times and unanswered voicemails
  • One long-term client downgraded review citing deteriorated service over recent months

What reviews say by service

Auto Insurance
Brokers save clients significant money (example: $60/month cheaper than competitors); praised for patience in complex cases
Home & Property Insurance
Professional, prompt service with clear explanations of coverage and options
Independent Multi-Carrier Broker
Responsive research and follow-up; staff compare multiple carriers to find best fit

How it compares

  • Rated 4.7 against a 4.08 average across the 263 auto insurance businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 97% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method
Star rating 79
Review volume 100
Review recency 100
Review sentiment 64
Profile completeness 100
Verification 30

Rating breakdown

5
844
4
28
3
5
2
1
1
62

Common questions

Can I get a quick quote?
Yes. Multiple reviewers report quotes within 10 minutes. Online quote requests are available, though response times vary.
Do they explain what I'm buying?
Yes. Clients frequently mention brokers taking time to detail coverage options and explain their recommendations.
What's pet insurance cost?
Their website lists pet insurance starting from $100 a year.

Similar insurance agency nearby

Tompkins Insurance Services Ltd
43 low data

Tompkins Insurance Services Ltd

5.0(1)

Limited review evidence available: one five-star rating. The business serves auto and life insurance across Canada. More detail would require additional customer feedback.

Auto InsuranceLife Insurance
Advanced Business Insurance
40 low data

Advanced Business Insurance

1.0(1)✓ Google-verified

Not enough recent reviews yet to synthesise a reliable sentiment read for this business.

Home & Property InsuranceBusiness & Commercial Insurance
InsuranceHotline.com
83

InsuranceHotline.com

4.6(621)✓ Google-verified

Most customers experience quick, friendly service with agents who compare options and deliver lower rates than they currently pay. Standout staff like Xanthia and Terri Matson build trust through patience and knowledge. However, some callers report quotes that jump dramatically between online estimates and broker conversations, or feel unheard during calls, creating doubt about pricing transparency.

Auto InsuranceHome & Property InsuranceLife Insurance

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-07-24